Dear Goldy,
I’m in my upper thirties and have a very well-paying job. I’m really good at what I do and get compensated well. I’ve lived on my own for a few years. I have more than enough money to cover my rent, bills, and expenses and have some money put away in savings. I’m not telling you that to boast; I’m telling you this because it has everything to do with my question.
I moved out of my parents’ house, not only because I felt it was time; I was in my thirties, and I didn’t need to save every penny for when I would get married. I moved out mainly because my parents aren’t wealthy people. They’re not poor either, but I had younger siblings at home, and I didn’t want my living there to contribute to added household expenses. My parents wouldn’t let me pay rent or contribute to household expenses. They always said it was their responsibility to provide for and support their children in their house; food needed to be bought, lights had to be on... They weren’t spending extra for me. They weren’t sending me a message either. I chose to move out. It was time.
I have an apartment and a car, and I pay my bills, with extra money saved in the bank and conservatively invested in stocks. But I wanted to help my parents. I had younger siblings, some teenagers, at home. My parents never said a word, but I knew they couldn’t spend money frivolously and really looked at what was spent. I don’t remember exactly how or when, but I gave my father an envelope, saying it was my time to help because I had the means to help now. Of course, he thanked me, which I hated and didn’t want. This turned into me leaving the envelope on the dining room table during one of my visits, usually at the beginning of each month. He never said anything, and neither did I. But if I am able to help my family, I want to.
Now I’m seriously dating someone. We had the financial conversation a little while ago. Thankfully, no surprises. Rather, I should say, I wasn’t surprised, but “Avi” was surprised when I told him about the money I’ve been giving my parents for these last few years. He said it was great that I was helping them but then asked if I was planning on continuing it after I was married. Honestly, I hadn’t given it much thought. Some of my siblings have gotten married, but I haven’t lessened the amount I give them. I just don’t want my parents to struggle, and I want them to have a chance to enjoy themselves. But now, the question was right in front of me. Avi said it was great that I had been helping, but now the extra money (that I give my parents) can be used toward a house or other expenses that a married couple building a family may have.
I know Avi is right, but I can’t imagine having that conversation with my parents. We don’t speak about that money. It’s just something that’s done. But now, if things continue with Avi, hopefully, it’ll lead to a wedding (which I am not expecting my parents to pay for, but we’ll discuss it if they insist on contributing). How can I bring this up with my parents, my father? I can’t help them anymore because I’ll “need” the money now. How do I say that they’re on their own, but I’m here if they ever need me? I want to put off this conversation. I don’t want to have this conversation. I don’t even know if my parents have discussed this between themselves, what will happen to the money once I get married. Maybe they have. But I don’t know.
How should I do it?
Bracha/Brenda
Thank you for your email, Bracha/Brenda.
You don’t need me to tell you that what you’ve been doing for your parents is amazing. Not many would think to help them once they’re out of the house. They would think, “They’re not paying for me anymore. I’ve lightened the load.” I’m sure the first few times, it was embarrassing for both you and your father when you gave him the envelope. Switching to leaving the envelope on the table, with no words exchanged, was a brilliant solution.
You’ve done all that you can (and more) to help your parents and siblings, but now it’s your turn. Now you’ll have the obligations of a wife to a husband. I’m sure “Avi” didn’t say or demand that you stop helping your parents. I can’t imagine that if he did, you wouldn’t have questions about it, about how heartless he could seem. I’m sure you indeed surprised Avi with your news, but in a good way. He now truly sees your heart and your hakaras hatov. There’s so much more I can say, but let’s get down to business.
Did Avi say that you need to stop helping your parents, or did he suggest stopping? There’s a difference. I’m sure Avi doesn’t want your parents’ lives to be any harder than necessary, but I can also understand what Avi meant by asking/suggesting that your helping stop. The money that both of you earn should be put toward building a life and family together. But you did write that you hadn’t given “much thought” to this. What is “much thought?” Is it what you would do once you got married? I’m sure the thought crossed your mind, and now, as I always say, once married, decisions are made by two instead of just you.
I don’t think Avi is “mean” or “cruel,” as some may think, because he wants to focus on his family and have the money his future wife earns be put toward a better life. Maybe you won’t need the money to buy a house right away, but let’s face it, expenses are only going up. The money may be needed down the road. Avi is thinking logically.
This is a conversation that you need to have with your father. I’m sure your father and mother will understand if your assistance needs to come to an end because you are now trying to focus on building a life with your husband. You didn’t allude to the fact that your parents were on the brink of poverty; you wrote that they couldn’t spend frivolously. I hope your parents won’t be destitute without your help. Hopefully, your father has been putting some money into savings or investing it and not just spending the money that you have been giving them.
This is a conversation you need to have with your father and Avi, separately. How do you feel about stopping altogether? Would you rather gradually stop, giving a little less each month? Did Avi ask how you felt about this, or was it just, “Well, you need to stop helping your parents because we’ll need the money. Go tell your father it’s over”? Or was it more like, “It would be ideal if you could continue what you’ve been doing, but looking at this practically, as a new family, we’ll be needing that money. There will be more expenses as a married couple than as a single person. I know it’ll be hard, but how do you want to handle it?” I think it was more like he said something in the middle. He didn’t demand you stop helping, but maybe he didn’t ask what your feelings were on the matter.
If this is something that bothers you, which it seems to, speak with Avi about your feelings if, in fact, this is the man who you think you’ll stand under the chuppah with. You need to discuss what this means to you and what your fears are, and you need to have the same conversation with your father. I’m sure both men will be understanding, and whatever is decided will be the right decision, one that you will feel good about as well. You’ll never stop worrying about your parents, but you may be able to have peace of mind.
Hatzlachah to you all!
Goldy Krantz is an LMSW and a lifelong Queens resident, guest lecturer, and author of the shidduch dating book “The Best of My Worst” and children’s book “Where Has Zaidy Gone?” She can be contacted at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Goldy is an experienced dating coach offering private sessions. To inquire, contact her at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
