My daughter has been asking me to write this article since the moment the incident happened. And I wanted to, but I didn’t know how to approach it. Should I advise singles what not to do? But then again, I always say to do everything possible to try to meet your bashert and put yourself out there because no one will see you if you stay at home. This person did exactly that, put himself out there, but it didn’t feel right. Could he have been celebrating the Yom Tov too hard by the time he met me? Perhaps, so his delivery was off. And he did ignore or not pay attention when I mentioned more than once that I had to go. I’ll lay out the scenario, and you can tell me what to think of it and if I should try to track this fellow down, but then again, even if I find him, I don’t know that I can help him.
One night over Yom Tov, I was walking with my children at a hurried pace because of the cold weather. All of a sudden, a young man, whom I’ll name Yossi, stopped me with the exact words of the title of this article: “I hope you don’t think I’m weird, but I need to find a shidduch. Do you know anybody I can date?” To say that this was the last thing I was expecting to be asked would be an understatement. I thought he wanted to know what time it was or where a certain shul was located. No. He wanted a wife. So, he stopped a woman walking hunched over against the cold, at a hurried pace (as mentioned), holding the hands of two children.
“What?” I asked, very confused. Was he approaching a stranger and literally asking for a shidduch? So many thoughts ran through my head, but one that stood out was, “He’s really taking a chance and putting himself out there.” I looked at my kids. My son was happily laughing to himself, and my daughter was looking very confused. “Does he know who you are?” she whispered. I doubted he knew who I was because it was dark out and he literally was just walking by. I could have been anyone. Maybe Hashem put me in his path for a reason, I thought.
I told him that I was short on time, but to tell me about himself quickly and what he was looking for. As soon as he started off with high school information, I asked him to fast-forward to the last five years, what he was currently doing, and what type of woman he was looking for. Even if you offered to pay me $500, to this day, I would not be able to tell you what this young man did or what his plan was. He couldn’t answer the question. He spoke about two yeshivos he studied in and how close he was with a specific rav I didn’t know, which shocked him because “he’s a great talmid chacham.” I assured him that the rav probably was, but I didn’t know who he was, and this wasn’t telling me anything about him. He said he was 29 and then told me that he “wants to marry a woman who is beautiful inside and out. I mean truly. Looks don’t matter. Job doesn’t matter. I’ll do whatever she wants me to. I’ll be the best husband. But she has to have a beautiful neshamah.” Oyyyyyy.
I looked at my daughter, who looked at me. Like my readers, my daughter knows what I think about these types of descriptions of people: unrealistic and not telling me anything concrete. I asked this fellow for his name and if he lived in the neighborhood. He said that he was staying with friends for Yom Tov. I know who the friend is; more importantly, his friend knows my father. I told him that after Yom Tov was over, he should tell his friend to speak with David ____ and he could get my information that way so we could continue this conversation. And then I began to say goodbye. But Yossi couldn’t remember my father’s name. I tried another tactic: “Do your cousins have the Queens Jewish Link in their home?” He didn’t know. I told him that he should ask, and if they did, my contact email is in it. Just look for Goldy Krantz. He could find me that way. Big mistake. I quickly explained why my information is in the QJL: “I write a column. My email address is in my byline.” But, of course, as soon as I told him I wrote a column, my daughter proudly said, “She writes the dating column. She also wrote two dating books.” I love that my daughter is proud of her mom and what I do, but at this point, I was able to tell that Yossi wasn’t of completely sound mind and body. I wanted to continue to my destination and husband. But Yossi got so excited and said it was “hashgachah pratis” that we met because he was just walking along and it just popped into his head to ask me for a shidduch when we were passing each other.
I told him that I wanted to help, but didn’t know many single women, and he hadn’t even given me the basics of what type of woman he was looking for, so he should get in contact with me at a later date when he could give me specifications about himself and what type of woman he wanted to marry, other than one “beautiful inside and out.” Yossi wouldn’t hear of it. We met there, and it “must be” because Hashem knows that I know his wife. All I have to do is “connect them.” I explained that he was mistaken, but maybe I could help him get in touch with a shadchan. But offhand, I don’t know any single women 25–30. (I don’t. I’m sorry.) I excused myself, telling him to email me, but Yossi started talking and talking about what’s important to him and what he wants from life in the future, and it was nothing like telling me what his five-year plan was.
This situation turned from a sweet one into one that I wanted to extricate myself and my children from ASAP. I stopped him and said I really had to be going. It was cold, my children were with me… he knew how to get in touch with me (two ways). I turned and began walking away with my children, but Yossi wasn’t finished. He walked a few feet with us. Finally, as a wife, mother, and person, I spoke up. “This isn’t the time or the place. You have my information. I’m leaving.” I admire when people have perseverance, but not like this. Approaching a woman in the dark with children and asking her to redt you a shidduch is odd, but also weird and touching on rude when you don’t listen to the words I said when I needed to leave, which makes me think he was slightly inebriated. I would try to help him another time. And now I was sure that Yossi may have had one too many l’chaims before he ran into me. This isn’t a situation or person I wanted my children around. Just because someone is frum and looks the part doesn’t mean they are sane and normal. I was making a judgment call. Thankfully, before I had to say anything else, my husband walked up to us (because I had not met him when and where I said I would, so he went to look for his family). Yossi shook my husband’s hand and pulled him in for a “man hug,” which my husband was not having any part of. Yossi started speaking excitedly to my husband, and that’s when my husband did what I was not able to do. “You know where to find her information to email her. We have to go.” With that, he took my daughter’s hand and started walking away, making sure I followed him.
Why am I writing about this? Why do I have questions? Well, truly, I would have loved to have helped Yossi, but I speak the truth. I don’t know any single young women, and I don’t have the time to devote to singles and helping them find a zivug. I’ve always said that a shadchan should have the time to assist those who come to them for help. But was this Yossi asking for help? Was it a moment when the schnapps may have gotten the better of him? If he was thinking clearly, would he have approached a stranger walking on the street? I asked him the important questions of what he was doing and what type of woman he was looking to date, and both received rambling responses. If someone was sincerely looking and asking another for help, wouldn’t he have had more direct answers? I told him two ways of contacting me, as did my husband. But Yossi never contacted me.
I’ve written before that I’m not someone who gives my word lightly. I never say, “We’ll do lunch.” If I say, “I’ll call you back,” by hook or crook, I’ll call you back. Even if it’s to say that I can’t talk then and will call you another time. So, when I told Yossi I would try to help, I meant it. Maybe a friend of mine knows of a young woman for him, or maybe I can connect him with a shadchan whom he hasn’t dealt with yet. Do I contact the friend he was staying with or just forget about the meeting altogether? Was this a sincere ask or an inebriated act?
What do I do?
Hatzlachah to you all!
Goldy Krantz is an LMSW and a lifelong Queens resident, guest lecturer, and author of the shidduch dating book “The Best of My Worst” and children’s book “Where Has Zaidy Gone?” She can be contacted at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Goldy is an experienced dating coach offering private sessions. To inquire, contact her at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..