People are often surprised that we have kids in shidduchim.

They ask, “Are your kids ready to go out?”

I don’t know if we’re ready to have kids who go out. Some of the basic questions mechutanim ask, we don’t have an answer.

“Where do they daven on Shabbos?”

I daven in 4 shuls. I have a place I like Friday nights because they have a seder before Maariv, a place I like Shabbos morning because they have Hashkama, a place I like Shabbos Mincha because it gets me home in time to eat Seudah Shlishis with my family, and a place I like for Maariv because I enjoy davening in living rooms.

Should I put all that on the shidduch resume?

But yes, we have a daughter in shidduchim, and now also a son. (Pause for all the calls to come in for the son.)

But we don’t know whether we’re ready. We’re definitely not ready to make phone calls. I hate being on the phone. My #1 priority, when I’m on the phone, is to make it clear to the other person that I cannot wait to finish our conversation. That’s not a good message when you’re talking shidduchim.

And I don’t know anyone that these people listed under “references”. And some of them are the wrong kind of references to ask certain questions.

Like some of them are “family friends”, who always start with, “We don’t know the girl, but it’s an amazing family.”

“Oh, you say this family you’re super close with is amazing? I’ll take your word for it. I’m done.”

But what else do we ask? We don’t even have time to think. With girls, if someone gives you a boy’s name, you have one day before they bother you again. Even if that day is the middle day of a 3-day yom tov.

“So, did you do finish doing research?”

The boy’s family approved of you. Why are you dragging your feet on this? You can’t just trust their judgement, these people you don’t know? They had who-knows-how long, and they think it’s a good idea. For goodness sakes, how long does it take to find out his entire life story? More than two days? Look, if you can’t find anything you don’t like in two days of calling people they have carefully selected, who don’t always pick up the phone, why not spend the rest of your life with this guy?

I feel like when you’re putting together a resume, you should maybe pick references based on who would actually pick up the phone for a number they don’t know. But usually you pick them based on who you would trust to call you afterward to say, “Yeah, someone called to ask about your daughter. I told them only the good things.”

“Only good things, or only THE good things?”

So if you have a daughter, you have no time to think – you’re just calling people in a mad rush so that the shadchan doesn’t tell the boy’s family, “Forget your months of research. This is taking her two days. There are other girls out there.”

There’s a process: First we look at the list and say, “We don’t know these people. These are all their people.” So we call some people we know who live in the same town, so they can say, “We don’t know the guy, but his family seems nice. I see his father in shul sometimes.”

So now what? Now we ask our person, “Okay, here’s the list of names we got of people who live in the same town as you. Do you know any of them, at least?”

“Yeah, I think I know her friend’s father.”

“And how’s that family?”

“Amazing!”

So we stare at the list of references, and then we just pick a name and hope for the best.

Everyone is happy to help. Or at least when they finally call back. But not everyone helps as much as they think.

Firstly, they’re always on their guard. Their first thought is, “We don’t want to say anything to mess this up. Even if we have to lie.”

Be honest! If it’s not the right shidduch, we don’t want them to go out. No one gains anything by flying in from Chicago because the references were afraid of an awkward phone conversation.

But the reference’s goal is, “Even though we don’t know you, we want that first date to happen no matter what.” That way they can say, “I was part of it! I was a shliach!”

Just like there are shluchim to make the shidduch, Hashem can be sending shluchim to mess up the shidduch.

“I was a shliach! I messed things up with all the previous girls!”

Sure, the reference doesn’t want to say anything bad, but something the reference would consider bad isn’t necessarily something the boy or girl would consider bad. We’re not marrying you.

I think that’s why people come up with ridiculous questions. They’re just trying to get honest answers.

For example, if someone asks whether the boy wears laced shoes or slip-ons, the answer to this isn’t making or breaking the shidduch. From what I heard, they’re really trying to ask, “Does he care about bittul Torah?” Because if you ask that directly, the reference will always say he does. So instead, they figure, “I’ll ask about shoes. If he wears laces, then every time he takes his shoes off in middle of seder and puts them back on, he has to go wash his hands. That’s bittul Torah.”

Well, why’s he putting them back on in the first place? Is it not because he needs to get up anyway? Also, if he’s sliding off his shoes in middle of seder, what does that say about his willingness to be mevatel the people around him? And what if he has laced shoes but he does a little dance to slip them on?

So maybe that question has nothing to do with bittul Torah. Maybe they’re asking about his mental capacity: “Can he tie his own shoes? We have low standards here.”

And the reference has no idea which of these two questions you’re asking, so he doesn’t automatically know which one’s the “right” answer, and he answers honestly. And now you have an iron-clad answer to the question you were trying not to ask! For your sake, I hope you have at least 8 more of these questions that may or may not mean he cares, and you take the best out of 9. Like, “Does he use paper plates or real dishes?” Because paper plates equals less bittul Torah, unless he doesn’t wash the dishes anyway, because his mother does. What if his mother ties his shoes? So you really don’t know anything.

So one idea that my wife has is that if we’re on the girl’s side, we don’t even have to call his references. We can call our references and ask, “What kinds of questions did his parents ask?”

This is why it’s great to go second.

My wife also likes asking, “What does he do for fun?”

She asks the guy’s chavrusos. And every single one says, “Um, I don’t know. We just learn.”

You’re not going to get in trouble here. This isn’t a trick question. What about when he’s not learning?

“He’s always learning.”

“Oh, ok, thank you. That’s too intense for our daughter.”

“Nowaitwaitwait! He’s not always learning.”

“Ok. So what activities does he do?”

“I don’t know. All I do is learn.”

Right.

“Wait, did we interrupt your learning? Hang on, is he sitting across from you right now?!”

“No, he’s washing his hands.”

I have this great idea, where you call the boy himself and pretend you’re asking about one of the references on his list and see what kind of answers he gives.

“I’m calling about Refoel Schwab.”

“My married friend?”

“No, I mean Nochum Kagan.”

“Ok. But I think he’s engaged.”

Or, I don’t know, why don’t we call the parents themselves? You know -- the parents who have the child’s best interests at heart and have handled yeshiva farhers and PTA meetings about the child?

“No, that’s too weird. Isn’t that Chassidish?”

But I mean, instead of getting half “I don’t know for sure” answers from neighbors, why not call the parents, who actually helped write the resume?

“So what did you mean when you wrote 6 feet? Is he really six feet?”

“I mean he’s not five feet.”

“Also, did you ever teach him how to tie his shoes? No one else knew.”

Instead of two sets of infinite phone calls, why not do it in one? One extremely stressful call that if we mess up and say the wrong thing, there’s no one else we can call to try again?

It’s not like with references, where if the conversation doesn’t go great, you can always call the next reference. There are only two parents. And for all you know, the whole time you were talking to one parent, the other parent was sitting right next to them. Maybe it’s the kind of parent that can be completely silent while their spouse is on the phone; you don’t know.

Or maybe the shadchan should make the calls. This is a person who’s not afraid to talk on the phone, who already has the resume -- why not give her your list of questions and she gets back to you? And if it doesn’t work out, she has those questions answered for the next person!

“No, I don’t trust the shadchan. I want to ask the questions myself. But also I don’t.”


Mordechai Schmutter is a weekly humor columnist for Hamodia, a monthly humor columnist, and has written six books, all published by Israel Book Shop.  He also does freelance writing for hire.  You can send any questions, comments, or ideas to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.